AgainsttherofessionallayerIsaynothing;heisaublicentertainer,likeanyother,andbyhisskillinhisarticularsortheatleastfulfillsthefirstsocialdutyofman—thatofsuortinghimselfandhisfamilybyhisownlegitimateexertions。Butwhatistobesaidofthecrackamateur?Tomeheseemsoneofthemostcontemtibleofmankind。Heearnsnomoney,butdevoteshimself,forthemereselfishleasureofthething,tosomegame,whichhelaysdayindayout;hebreaksdownthesalutarydistinctionbetweentheamateurandtherofessional;eventuallyhisskilldesertshim,andheleavesbehindhimnothingthatisofservicetohisfellowmen—notabricklaid,notanacreloughed,notalinewritten,notevenafamilysuortedandeducatedbyhislabor。
Itistruethathehasrovidedentertainmentforacertainnumberofersons,buthehasneverhadthelucktosubmithimselftothetestbywhichwedemandthateveryentertainershouldjustifyhischoiceofacalling—thedemonstrationofthefactthattheubliciswillingtoayhimforhisentertainment。And,whenhisdayisover,whatisleft,noteventotheworld,buttohimself?Nothingbutanamethatisatonceforgotten,orisrememberedbystoutgentlemeninclubs。
Thelayingofgames,certainly,isathingwhichisnotworthdoingwell。Butthatdoesnotrovethatitisnotworthdoingatall,astheroverbwould,byimlication,ersuadeus。Thereisnothingmoreagreeableandsalutarythanlayingagamewhichonelikes,andthecircumstanceofdoingitbadlyinterfereswiththeleasureofnorealdevoteeofanyastime。Themanwhomindswhetherornothewinsisnotruesortsman—whichobservationistrite,buttheruleitimliesisseldomobserved,andcomarativelyfeweolereallylaygamesforthesheerenjoymentofthelaying。Isthisnotrovedbytherevalenceandoularityofhandicas?Whyshouldweexecttobegivenointsunlessitbethatwewishtowinbymeansotherthanourownskill?
"Ah!but,
"myreadermaysay,
"theweakerlayerwantstoreceiveointsinorderthathemaygivethestrongeroneabettergame。
"Really,Idonotbelievethatthatisso。Possible,sometimes,astrongandvaingloriouslayermaywishtogiveoints,inorderthathisvictorymaybethemorenotable。ButIdonotthinkthateventhisisthetrueexlanation。That,Isusect,wasgiventometheotherdaybythesecretaryofalawn-tennistournament,inwhichIlayed。
"Whyallthisnonsenseofhandicas?Whynotletusbesquarelybeaten,anddonewithit?
"Iaskedhim。
"Because,
"Herelied,
"ifwedidnotgivehandicas,noneofthelessgoodlayerswouldenter。
"Isthatnotaconfessionthatthemajorityofushavebothrealizedthetruevaluedoingatrivialthingbadly,foritsownsake,andmustneedshaveourmindsbuoyedandcheatedintoafalsesenseofexcellence?
Moreoveritisnotonlysuchintrinsicallytrivialthingsasgamesthatareworthdoingbadly。Thisisatruthwhich,oddlyenough,weaccetfreelyofsomethings—butnotofothers—andasathingwhichwearequitecontenttodowillletmeinstanceacting。Acting,atitsbest,canbeagreatart,athingworthdoingsuremelywell,thoughitsworth,likethatofallinterretativearts,islessenedbyitsevanescence。Foritworksintheimermanentmediumofhumanfleshandblood,andthethingthattheactorcreate—forwhatwecallaninterretativeartistisreallyacreativeartistworkinginaerishablemedium—isanimressionuon,anemotionorathoughtarousedin,themindsofanaudience,andisincaableofrecord。
Acting,then,letmeostulate—thoughIhaveonlysketchedeversobrieflytheroofofmybelief—canbeagreatart。Butisanyoneeverdeterredfromtakingartinamateurtheatricalsbytheconsiderationthathecannotactwell?Notabitofit!Andquiterightlynot,foractingisoneofthethingsaboutwhichIamwritingthisessay—thethingsthatareworthdoingbadly。
Anothersuchthingismusic;butheretheroverbialfallacyagainexertsitsower,asitdoesnot,forsomeobscureandunreasoningdiscrimination,inacting。Mosteoleseemtothinkthatiftheycannotsing,orlaytheiano,fiddle,orsackbut,admirablywell,theymustnotdoanyofthesethingsatall。Thattheyshouldnotindiscriminatelyforcetheirinferiorerformancesuontheublic,orevenuontheiracquaintances,Iadmit。Butthatthereisnolace
"inthehome
"forinferiormusicalerformances,isanuntruththatIflatlydeny。
Howmanysonsanddaughtershavenot,withaverysmalltalent,giventheirarents—andeventhelessfondlyrejudicedearsoftheirfriends—greatleasurewiththesingingofsimlesongs?Thenonedaytherecomestothesingertheserentofdissatisfaction;singinglessonsaretaken,and—iftheuilisofmoderatetalentandmodestdisosition—limitationsarediscovered。Andthen,inninecasesoutoften,thesingingisdroed,likeahotenny。Howmanyfathershavenotbanishedmusicfromtheirhomesbyencouragingtheirdaughterstotakesinginglessons?Yetahomemaybethefresherforsingingthatwoulddeservebrickbatsataarishconcert。
Imayauseheretonoticethecuriousexcetionthateolewhocannotonanyaccountbeersuadedtosinginthedrawing-room,oreveninthebath,willwithouthesitationulifttheirtunelessvoicesatreligiousmeetingsorinchurch。Thereisaerfectlygoodandhonorableexlanationofthis,Ibelieve,butitbelongstotherealmofmetahysicsandisbeyondmyresentscoe。
Thiscursedbelief,thatifathingisworthdoingatall,itisworthdoingwell,isthecauseofagreatimoverishmentinourrivatelife,andalso,tosomeextent,oftheloweringofstandardsinourubliclife。Forthistenetofroverbialfaithhastwoeffectsonsmalltalents:itleadsmodestersonsnottoexercisethematall,andimmodestersonstoattemttodosotoomuchandtoforcethemselvesuontheublic。Itleadstothedecayofletter-writingandofthekeeingofdiaries,and,assurely,itleadstotheublicationofmemoirsanddiariesthatshouldremainlockedinthewritersdesks。
ItleadsMr。Blanknottowriteversesatall—whichhemightverywelldo,forthesakeofhisownhainess,andfortheamusementofhisfriends—anditleadsMissDashtoestertheoverworkededitorsofvariousjournalswithherunsuccessfulimitationsofMr。delaMare,Mr。Yeats,andDr。Bridges。Theresultisthatournationalartisticlifenowsuffersfromtwogreatneeds:Awideramateurracticeofthearts,andahigher,moreexclusive,rofessionalstandard。Untiltheseareachievedweshallnotgetthebestoutofoursouls。
Thetruthis,Iconceive,thatthereisformostofusonlyonething—beyond,ofcourse,ourdutiesofcitizenshiandourersonaldutiesassons,orhusbands,orfathers,daughters,orwives,ormothers—thatisworthdoingwell—thatistosay,withallourenergy。Thatonethingmaybewriting,oritmaybemakingsteam-engines,orlayingbricks。Butafterthattherearehundredsofthingsthatareworthdoingbadly,withonlyartofourenergy,forthesakeoftherelaxationtheybringus,andforthecontactswhichtheygiveuswithourminds。AndthesoonerEnglandrealizesthis,asonceshedid,thehaier,themorecontented,themoregracious,willourlandbe。
Thereareeven,Imaintain,thingsthatareinthemselvesbetterdonebadlythanwell。Considerfishing,whereoneswholeleasureisoftensoiledbyhavingtokillafish。Now,ifonecouldcontrivealwaystotrytocatchafish,andnevertodoso,onemight—butthatisanotherstory。
请勿开启浏览器阅读模式,否则将导致章节内容缺失及无法阅读下一章。
相邻推荐:每天读点好英文:看见死亡的双眼 我一棍子下去,你可能会死 综武:匪天子!开局绑架北凉世子 上司太欺人 失忆娇妻:萌宝戏耍酷爹地 情绪力 倒霉帅王爷:妃要休夫 我是猫 仕途之步步高升 每天读一点暖心英文:你是最好的自己 龙飞成神 中学生怎样阅读写作 倾世医妃要休夫 竹马情不美 八零真千金:三天后离婚?难啊! 每天读点好英文:沉默的长夜 怎样思考,就有怎样的生活 鬼神人生 寻找人生的坐标(英文爱藏双语系列) 反派!我曾守护世间,今成魔